Ga naar de inhoud
Radio Logo
PodcastsOverheidFree Speech Arguments

Free Speech Arguments

Institute for Free Speech
Nieuwste aflevering

58 afleveringen

  • Free Speech Arguments

    Free Speech Arguments – Are AI “Trade Secrets” Protected by the First Amendment? (X.AI LLC v. Rob Bonta)

    18-11-2026 | 45 Min.
    Episode 59: X.AI LLC v. Rob Bonta 
    X.AI LLC v. Rob Bonta, argued before Judges Johnnie B. Rawlinson, Milan D. Smith, Jr., and Danielle J. Forrest of the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on November 18, 2026. Argued by James Y. Xi (on behalf of X.AI LLC) and Joseph Meeker (on behalf of the state of California).
    Case Summary, from the Brief for Appellant:  
    Like many companies in the burgeoning artificial intelligence (“AI”) industry, X.AI LLC (“xAI”) develops generative artificial intelligence models, or gen-AI models for short. Gen-AI models are software programs that simulate human intelligence to create original content and perform a wide range of tasks—everything from answering trivia questions and summarizing documents to generating images and videos. To train its models, xAI compiles “datasets”—collections of information derived from different sources. xAI plugs those datasets into its AI models, which users can use to generate new content. Those models, however, are only as good as their training, which is only as good as the data on which they are trained. Unsurprisingly then, xAI (like its competitors) dedicates substantial resources to identifying and developing high-quality training data, particularly from sources its competitors are not using. And unsurprisingly, xAI (like its competitors) treats such information as proprietary trade secrets. As companies race to build the next successful gen-AI product, the competitive advantage provided by data quality and training efficiency has become increasingly important… 
    Though companies in the industry fiercely guard such information from their competitors, California Assembly Bill 2013 (“A.B.2013”) requires AI companies to disclose that information to the public. But just as the government could not require, e.g., Coca-Cola to reveal its formula for Coke to the public, California cannot compel AI companies to reveal proprietary information about the datasets they use to train their gen-AI models. In fact, A.B.2013 is unconstitutional thrice over: It violates the First Amendment by compelling xAI to disseminate confidential information about its generative AI models. It violates the Takings Clause by forcing xAI to disclose its economically valuable and fiercely protected trade-secret property rights without any promise of compensation. And it is unconstitutionally vague because it fails to provide regulated parties with sufficient clarity about which datasets it covers and how much detail about that proprietary information they must provide. 
    Statement of the Issues from the Brief for Appellant:    
    Whether xAI is likely to succeed in showing that A.B.2013 violates xAI’s First Amendment rights. 
    Whether xAI is likely to succeed in showing that A.B.2013 effects an uncompensated taking in violation of the Takings Clause. 
    Whether xAI is likely to succeed in showing that A.B.2013 is unconstitutionally vague. 
    Resources:    
    CourtListener Docket 
    Brief for Appellant 
    Answering Brief for Defendant-Appellee 

    The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform.
  • Free Speech Arguments

    Can the Government Mandate Pronoun Use? (Defending Education, et al. v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al.)

    16-11-2026 | 54 Min.
    Episode 58: Defending Education, et al. v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al. 
    Defending Education, et al. v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al., argued before Judges Scott M. Matheson, Jr., Allison H. Eid, and Kelly Harrison Rankin (Chief U.S. District Judge, sitting by designation) of the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit on November 16, 2026. Argued together with Doxa Enterprises, LTD d/b/a Born Again Used Books v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al., and Committee of Five, Inc. d/b/a XX-XY Athletics, v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al. Argued by Paul Draper (on behalf of Defending Education), Chris Schandevel (on behalf of XX/XY Athletics and Born Again Used Books) and Janna K. Fischer (on behalf of the Colorado Civil Rights Division and all defendants).   
    Case Summary, from the Institute for Free Speech website:  
    Gender ideology and pronoun use are among the most contentious cultural and political debates of the day. But the First Amendment protects your right to participate in that debate, no matter which side you’re on. 
    Colorado’s new anti-discrimination law compels speech by forcing speakers to express a message they don’t believe in by using pronouns (and other gendered language) to prevent individuals from feeling “unwelcome.” That’s why the Institute for Free Speech filed amicus briefs in three related cases before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit. 
    In the law, the state advances its own viewpoint by mandating use of non-standard pronouns and forbidding other perspectives. As IFS’s brief states, “No government can police language to allow messages it likes, while prohibiting those it disapproves—even when the language might ‘provoke[e] offense and condemnation.’” 
    Issues Presented, from the Appellant Opening Brief:    
    CADA as amended by H.B. 25-1312 arguably prohibits Plaintiffs’ speech, Defendants have not disavowed enforcement, and Defendants have used CADA to punish similar speech in the past. Do Plaintiffs have standing? 
    In the district court, Defendants declined to respond to Plaintiffs’ arguments regarding CADA’s constitutionality, so they have forfeited the merits. Thus, if the Court agrees that Plaintiffs likely have standing, should it grant a preliminary injunction? 
    Alternatively, this Court can resolve the merits itself because CADA’s constitutionality presents a pure legal question and Colorado has declined to satisfy its burden to establish the law’s constitutionality. Does CADA likely violate the First and Fourteenth Amendments because it compels speech, discriminates based on content and viewpoint, is overbroad, and is vague? 
    In First Amendment cases, the likelihood of success on the merits is usually the determinative factor. Do the remaining preliminary-injunction factors favor an injunction because Plaintiffs likely have standing and Defendants have forfeited the merits?
    Resources:    
    Appellant Opening Brief 
    CourtListener Docket 
    Institute for Free Speech amicus brief 
    Institute for Free Speech press release 

    The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform.
  • Free Speech Arguments

    Can the Government Cap Screen Time for Minors Under the First Amendment? (NetChoice v. Jay Jones)

    28-10-2026 | 53 Min.
    Episode 57: NetChoice v. Jay Jones
    NetChoice v. Jay Jones, argued before Judges J. Harvie Wilkinson III, Roger L. Gregory, and DeAndrea Gist Benjamin of the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit on October 28, 2026. Argued by Erin E. Murphy (on behalf of NetChoice) and Tillman J. Breckenridge (on behalf of the Commonwealth of Virginia).  
    Case Summary, from the Appellees’ Brief: 
    Virginia Senate Bill 854 is one of the latest attempts in a long line of government efforts to restrict new forms of constitutionally protected expression based on concerns about their potential effects on minors. Books, movies, rock music, and video games have all been accused of endangering minors in the past. Today, similar debates rage about “social media.” Those debates are important, and the government may certainly participate in them. But the First Amendment does not take kindly to government efforts to resolve them. The Constitution instead leaves the power to decide what speech and how much of it is appropriate for minors where it belongs: with their parents. 
    Nevertheless, several states have recently enacted statutes restricting minors’ access to some of the most popular “social media” services. Courts across the country have held that these laws violate the First Amendment. And rightly so. States may certainly take steps to protect minors who use “social media,” but requiring minors to obtain parental consent before accessing those websites is not a narrowly tailored means of advancing a legitimate governmental interest… 
    Like similar state efforts, SB854 violates the First Amendment. The law bans minors from spending more than an hour a day on a covered “social media” website unless they obtain parental consent. SB854, moreover, does not limit its reach to “social media” as that term is commonly understood. It defines “social media” broadly to reach websites like YouTube, blogging platforms like Dreamwidth, and messaging boards like College Confidential. By restricting the ability of minors (and adults, who must now prove their age) to access these websites, Virginia has restricted millions of Virginians “from engaging in the legitimate exercise of First Amendment rights.” 
    Issues Presented, from the Opening Brief for Appellant:   
    Did the district court err in concluding that NetChoice was likely to establish that Virginia’s Parental Control Provision violates the First Amendment? 
    Did the district court err in weighing the public interest, the balance of equities, and irreparable harm against Virginia? 
    Resources:   
    CourtListener Docket 
    Opening Brief for Appellant 
    Appellees’ Brief 
    ACLU Amicus Brief in Support of Plaintiff-Appellees 

    The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform.
  • Free Speech Arguments

    Can the Government Withhold Court Recordings from Citizens? (Samantha Hallman v. Travis Reeds, et al.)

    21-10-2026 | 42 Min.
    Episode 56: Samantha Hallman v. Travis Reeds, et al. 
    Samantha Hallman v. Travis Reeds, et al., argued before Senior Judge Eugene E. Siler, Jr., Senior Judge Jeffrey S. Sutton, and Judge Karen Nelson Moore of the United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on October 21, 2026. Argued by Sophia Miller (on behalf of Samantha Hallman) and William H. Horton (on behalf of the Oakland County judges). 
    Case Summary, from the Corrected Brief for Appellees: 
    Appellant [Dr. Samantha Hallman] sought access to and copies of audio and video recordings of court proceedings from a Michigan district court and circuit court. The requests were denied pursuant to a Michigan Supreme Court rule requiring trial courts to enter an administrative order adopting a policy regarding access to and copying of court recordings from a list of permissible choices. The district court had entered an administrative order which does not allow access to or copying of such recordings. The circuit court had entered an administrative order allowing the viewing of such recordings but not copying. Appellant claims she has a First Amendment right to both access and copying. The District Court dismissed, holding the Michigan Supreme Court rule and the trial court administrative orders do not implicate the First Amendment. 
    Statement of Issues, from the Corrected Brief for Appellees:  
    Did the District Court err in deciding the motion under Fed. R. Civ. P. 12(b)(6) and should this Court review that issue since it was not raised or decided in the District Court? Appellant says “yes.” Appellee says “no.” The issue was not raised or decided in the District Court. 
    Did the District Court err in holding there is no constitutional right to access or copy recordings of trial court proceedings? Appellant says “yes.” Appellee says “no.” District Court said “no.” 
    Resources:  
    District Court Opinion   
    Appellants’ Brief 
    Corrected Brief for Appellees 
    CourtListener Docket 

    The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform.
  • Free Speech Arguments

    Can the Government Withhold Arts Funding Based on Viewpoint? (Rhode Island Latino Arts v. National Endowment for the Arts)

    07-10-2026 | 53 Min.
    Episode 55: Rhode Island Latino Arts v. National Endowment for the Arts
    Rhode Island Latino Arts v. National Endowment for the Arts, argued before Judges David J. Barron, Julie Rikelman, and Seth R. Aframe of the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit on October 7, 2026. Argued by Vera Eidelman (on behalf of Rhode Island Latino Arts) and Jennifer L. Utrecht (on behalf of the federal government / National Endowment for the Arts).
    Case Summary, from the Corrected Brief for Appellants:  
    The NEA opens applications for grants from the Grants for Arts Project—the NEA’s premier grant program—on a semiannual basis. Depending on the availability of congressionally appropriated funds, approved grant applications will typically receive between $10,000 to $100,000 for “specific, definable activities” outlined in the application. In advance of these application cycles, NEA historically has encouraged applications for projects covering certain topics, which often reflect issues of contemporary significance or other administration priorities… 
    Approximately three weeks before the application deadline for the Grants for Arts Project, President Trump signed Executive Order 14168, “Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government.”… The NEA responded by updating its grant procedures to require applicants to certify that federal funds would not be used to promote gender ideology, in compliance with the Executive Order. 
    Statement of Issues, from the Corrected Brief for Appellants: 
    Whether the district court erred in concluding that the process outlined in the NEA’s final notice is unlawful or arbitrary and capricious under the APA. 
    Whether the district court erred in concluding that the final notice is facially unconstitutional. 
    Whether the district court’s remedy is overbroad.
    Resources:   
    Corrected Brief for Appellants 
    Brief for Plaintiffs-Appellees 
    District Court Summary Judgment Opinion 
    CourtListener Docket 

    The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform.
Meer Overheid podcasts
Over Free Speech Arguments
Presented by the Institute for Free Speech The Free Speech Arguments Podcast brings you oral arguments from important First Amendment free political speech cases across the country.
Podcast website

Luister naar Free Speech Arguments, De Dienst en vele andere podcasts van over de hele wereld met de radio.net-app

Ontvang de gratis radio.net app

  • Zenders en podcasts om te bookmarken
  • Streamen via Wi-Fi of Bluetooth
  • Ondersteunt Carplay & Android Auto
  • Veel andere app-functies