Hallmark Mysteries & More

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.
Eric and Andrea kick off mystery month with Good Witch: Curse from a Rose, the 2019 Halloween movie that turned out to be the final Good Witch film. Andrea gives it a full five stars, and Eric makes the case that the whole franchise is still the bar for Hallmark series. The only real dispute is whether Middleton's official population would survive a census.
What You'll Hear:
• Andrea's five-star verdict, and why a town of 3,017 people should not look that big from the air
• The pumpkin regatta neither host remembered, and why Cassie feels a lot like Andrea
• Why Eric thinks Good Witch set the standard, from Cassie and Sam's chemistry to Hallmark paying for two American leads
• The franchise timeline from 2008 to 2021, and how Curse from a Rose became the last movie
• What didn't land: no Grace, a softer Nick, and a cast too big for everyone to get a turn
• Eric's complaint about the mummy marathon and bowling events that never made it on screen
• Cassie and Sam's first married Halloween, plus Martha's surprisingly wise line about love
• Trivia: the Middleton monster cameo, a truck that changes color mid-scene, and what Catherine Bell planned to do before acting
• What to watch next: Kentucky Roses and Acorn's Queens of Mystery
Chapters:
0:00 - Mystery Month Starts in Middleton
1:07 - The Recap: Cassie's College Roommate Comes to Town
1:46 - Andrea's Five-Star Verdict (and a Census Problem)
4:31 - Andrea's Inner Cassie and the Pumpkin Regatta
5:44 - Eric's Take: Why Good Witch Is the Bar
9:18 - The Last Good Witch Movie and a 13-Year Run
11:25 - What Didn't Work: No Grace and a Different Nick
13:50 - Where Was the Mummy Marathon?
14:53 - Standout Character: Cassie vs. the Whole Ensemble
16:49 - The Romance: Cassie and Sam, Tom and Martha
19:32 - What to Watch Next
20:37 - Trivia: Bessie, a Color-Changing Truck and Catherine Bell
22:26 - IMDb Rating and Coming Up Next
Andrea wants Hallmark to bring Good Witch back every Halloween. If they did, who gets the next movie built around them: Cassie and Sam again, Martha, Abigail, or someone else from Middleton?
New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.
#GoodWitch #CurseFromARose #CatherineBell #JamesDenton #LolitaDavidovich #CassieNightingale #Middleton #HallmarkHalloween #HalloweenMovies #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV
Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website. 

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.
Eric and Andrea review Pumpkin Regatta Romance, the Hallmark Channel fall movie starring Mishael Morgan and Corey Sevier, where two feuding dads, a pumpkin farm, and a boat shop all collide over a town race run in hollowed-out giant pumpkins. Yes, that is a real thing. Andrea gives it 4.5 stars, Eric lands a shade below, and both agree this is exactly the comfort food movie people mean when they say they miss old school Hallmark.
What You'll Hear:
• Andrea's farm-life reality check on chasing a tractor across a field (and a cow manure story nobody saw coming)
• Whether pumpkin regattas are real (they are, with races in Maine and Oregon)
• Why Ethan's mom Frankie and both dads make this a rare Hallmark movie with genuinely supportive parents
• The great Mr. and Mrs. debate: do you still call your friends' parents by their first names?
• The one gripe: how does Nadine not know Lola in a town this small?
• Rob Stewart (Sam Bishop on The Way Home) as a grumpy dad with range, and Eric finally placing Sharron Matthews from Frankie Drake Mysteries
• The Nadine and Ethan romance, including the dad interruption that stopped a kiss cold
• Two fall recommendations from the archives: Pumpkin Pie Wars (2016) and Harvest Moon (2015)
• Mishael Morgan trivia: her history-making Daytime Emmy win for The Young and the Restless
Chapters:
0:00 - Is This Hallmark's Wildest Premise Yet?
0:23 - Hallmark Preview Episode With Jenny Coming Soon
0:49 - Pumpkin Regatta Romance Recap and Andrea's Rating
2:32 - Tractors, Farm Life, and a Cow Manure Story
4:40 - Is the Pumpkin Regatta a Real Thing?
5:13 - Eric's Rating: Classic Hallmark Comfort Food
6:18 - Kate Pragnell, Jake Epstein, and Allie's Knowing Looks
7:54 - Frankie King and the Rare Supportive Hallmark Parents
9:10 - Mr. and Mrs. or First Names? Plus the "Real Date"
10:50 - The One Gripe: How Did Nadine Not Know Lola?
11:59 - Andrea's Standout: Rob Stewart from The Way Home
13:46 - Eric's Standout: Sharron Matthews from Frankie Drake
15:16 - The Romance: Mishael Morgan and Corey Sevier
17:28 - Corey Sevier's Résumé and a Jaz Ramsey Detour
17:58 - If You Liked This, Watch These
19:13 - Trivia: Mishael Morgan's Historic Daytime Emmy
20:27 - Up Next: A Night to Remember and Good Witch
Andrea says 4.5 stars and Eric says a shade below. Where do you land on Pumpkin Regatta Romance, and did you know pumpkin regattas were real before you watched it?
New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.
#PumpkinRegattaRomance #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #MishaelMorgan #CoreySevier #RobStewart #JakeEpstein #FallIntoLove #FallMovies #RomanceMovies #TheWayHome
Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website. 

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.
Garage Sale Mysteries is back after six years, and Eric and Andrea review Garage Sale Mysteries: Murder Takes the Stage, with Lori Loughlin returning as Jennifer Shannon. Andrea has been waiting for this one for a long time. Eric has spent years saying only one Garage Sale movie was any good. So did the new one change his mind, or did Andrea finally have to admit the series has its limits?
What You'll Hear:
• Andrea's five out of five, which she more or less decided before the opening credits
• Eric's surprisingly generous verdict, plus his reenactment of Jen investigating the dark room alone
• The little details superfans will catch, like the missing corner and the new diner
• How the true crime book club's Lizzie Borden reenactment gave the mystery a full, workable murder board
• Why Eric thinks this one finally delivered real suspects and real red herrings
• Steve Bacic's behind-the-scenes take on how quickly the cast fell back into rhythm
• How the movie worked around Hannah's limited screen time
• Real Lizzie Borden trivia, including what the famous playground rhyme gets wrong
• Hallmark and Chill picks from Murder, She Wrote, Mystery 101, Picture Perfect Mysteries, and Aurora Teagarden
Chapters:
0:00 - Can Garage Sale Mysteries Finally Win Eric Over?
2:00 - That Lizzie Borden Netflix Series (Andrea Lasted 14 Minutes)
4:10 - Practical Magic 2 and a Hunter King Lookalike
5:45 - Plot Enjoyment: Andrea's Five Out of Five
10:15 - Eric's Verdict: Begrudgingly Fantastic
14:05 - The Mystery: Red Herrings That Actually Work
16:55 - Romance Roundup: Jen and Jason
18:30 - Character Corner: Dani vs. Jason
19:45 - Trivia: The Real Lizzie Borden Case
21:55 - Hallmark and Chill Recommendations
23:30 - Next Week: Pumpkin Regatta Romance
Andrea gave it a five, Eric landed somewhere between a four and a four and a half. Where do you land, and did you guess the killer before Jen did?
New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.
#GarageSaleMysteries #MurderTakesTheStage #LoriLoughlin #SteveBacic #SarahStrange #KevinOGrady #LizzieBorden #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyMystery #CozyTV #HallmarkReview
Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website. 

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.
Eric and Andrea sit down with Dating the Delaneys, the 2022 Hallmark movie that reunites Rachel Boston and Paul Campbell ahead of their new pairing in Return to Santa this November. Three generations of Delaney women are dating at once, and Eric and Andrea do not agree on how well any of it holds up.
What You'll Hear:
• The 2026 Countdown to Christmas casting news, including why Eric is bracing himself for Rachel Boston and Paul Campbell's next movie together
• Andrea's rewatch verdict (a steep drop from the four stars she gave it back in 2022) versus Eric's defense of the movie, scene by scene
• Why the fake dating trope between Maggie and Michael works, and how their shared grief ties the romance together
• Emma's teenage dating storyline, the world's biggest slice of cake, and the software engineer date that had Eric howling
• Devon's wingwoman energy, the Make It Bake It Cake It subplot, and that pecan pie fall moment
• The grandma storyline and why three generations of romance actually landed for Eric
• What to watch next if you liked this one, including The Way Home and the upcoming Return to Santa
• A bowling scorecard continuity error, Rachel Boston's real-life chef husband, and other trivia
0:00 - Intro and the Rachel Boston/Paul Campbell Reunion
1:45 - 2026 Countdown to Christmas Casting Talk
5:15 - Behind the Scenes: Recording Three Movies and an AC Saga
7:30 - Dating the Delaneys: Synopsis and Star Ratings
9:15 - What Andrea Liked
12:30 - What Eric Liked
16:00 - What Andrea Didn't Like
18:30 - What Eric Didn't Like: The Cringe Software Engineer
20:00 - The Romance: Three Generations of Delaney Women
23:00 - Similar Watches: The Way Home and Return to Santa
24:15 - IMDb Score and Trivia
25:45 - Next Week's Review and the Sister, Sister Debate
Andrea gave this one four stars back in 2022. On the rewatch she landed closer to 1.5. Eric didn't budge an inch. Where do you land on Dating the Delaneys, and is the fake dating trope still working for you in 2026?
New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.
 #DatingTheDelaneys #HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #RachelBoston #PaulCampbell #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #CozyTV #RomanceMovies #ReturnToSanta #HallmarkReview #TheWayHome #FallMovies #HallmarkPodcast
Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website. 

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

We would love to hear from you. Send us your thoughts or suggestions.
Andrea and Eric are back with the first true fall movie of the season, Falling Into Place, starring Nathan Witte and Alvina August. Andrea gives it four stars, Eric lands at three and a half, and both agree the movie leans on just about every fall Hallmark trope there is. So does the chemistry and comfort food coziness win out over a plot with zero surprises? They break down the ratings, the standout supporting cast, and why Nathan Witte needs a real leading role of his own.
What You'll Hear:
• Andrea and Eric rate Falling Into Place separately (four stars vs. three and a half) and explain the gap
• The full rundown on Kaia and James's fall bucket list and why their chemistry carries a familiar plot
• The case for giving Nathan Witte a real leading role after years of second tier parts
• Why Mr. Winters (B.J. Harrison) steals every scene he's in
• A trivia detour into Nathan Witte's music project, Steel Afro
• The real life news about Stephanie Bennett's husband trading Hallmark sets for the fire department
• Three fall Hallmark movies Andrea and Eric recommend if Falling Into Place worked for you
• Instagram poll results on how their audience rated the movie
• What's coming next: Dating the Delaneys and the return of Garage Sale Mysteries
Chapters:
0:00 - Fall Vibes and a Scarecrow Joke
1:40 - Fan Mail, the Playlist, and What's Coming Next
3:45 - Falling Into Place: The Setup
5:15 - Andrea's Review: Four Out of Five Stars
9:30 - Eric's Review: Three and a Half Stars
12:00 - The Case for Nathan Witte as a Leading Man
14:15 - Kaia and James: Old Friends, Real Chemistry
16:30 - Standout Senior Character: Mr. Winters
18:15 - What Didn't Work (Feels, Not Reals)
20:15 - Fall Movie Recommendations
22:00 - Trivia: Steel Afro and a Real-Life Firefighter
23:45 - Instagram Poll Results and What's Next
Where do you land, Andrea's four stars or Eric's three and a half, and should Nathan Witte finally get a leading role of his own? Let us know in the comments.
New episodes every week. Subscribe and hit the bell so you never miss a Hallmark deep dive.
#HallmarkChannel #HallmarkMovies #HallmarkMysteries #HallmarkFans #FallingIntoPlace #NathanWitte #AlvinaAugust #StephanieBennett #CozyMystery #FallMovies #HallmarkFallMovies #CozyTV #RomanceMovies #HallmarkReview #GarageSaleMysteries #DatingTheDelaneys
Follow us on social media:
Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore
Youtube

Or visit our website. 

This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.